April 2001
Frequency Response:
20Hz to 20kHz +/- 0.5 dB
THD: under 0.05%
S/N Ratio: better than 90 dB Single-ended or Balanced Mode
Power Output:
8 Ohm Load: 160 Watts rms/channel, 4 Ohm Load: 320 Watts
rms/channel
Input Impedance: 100k-Ohm
Input Sensitivity: 2.5V
Dimensions: 5.5" x 12.5" x 16.5" (H x W x D)
Weight: 35 lb. each
Price: $2000. USD each
Monarchy Audio
380 Swift Ave., #21
S. San Francisco, CA 94080
Phone: 650-873-3055
Fax: 650-588-0335
E-mail: monarchy@earthlink.net
Website: http://www.monarchyaudio.com/
High-Power Hybrid Monos Make Music!
Do you ever wish you could find a
simple high power amplifier that
sounds as sweet as your favorite
little tube amp and yet can provide
the same kind of musically involving
presentation when pushing your
not-so-sensitive reference speakers
to relatively loud volume levels? Do
you also yearn for an amp that can
keep its composure while reproducing complex instrumental passages
along
with a wide range of dynamic gradations and inner detail? If
your answer was
yes, then you may want to take a close look at the Monarchy Audio
SE-160
single-ended class-A monoblock amplifiers.
The SE-160 is a relatively compact monophonic hybrid design that
couples a
6DJ8/6922-based tube input stage to a high-power MOSFET output
stage.
High-quality parts are used throughout, including a heavy-duty,
650-Watt
toroidal transformer per amplifier (1300 Watts per pair). Balanced
XLR
connectors, as well as high-quality, single-ended RCA jacks are
provided, as is
a female IEC connector for use with detachable AC power cords.
The amps are physically a bit smaller than one might expect for
units of this
power rating, but they are attractive, meaty packages, boasting
thick black
aluminum faceplates with heavy-duty gold-plated rack handles.
While one
wouldn’t rank them at the pinnacle of modern art, their appearance
is quite
respectable.
Each SE-160 monoblock uses a single dual-triode driver tube and
Monarchy’s
designer and CEO, Mr. C.C. Poon tells me that any 6.3 volt dual
triode having
the same pin configuration as the 6DJ8, such as the 6922, 7308,
6CG7/6FQ7,
E88CC, 6N1P, etc. can be substituted. No matching of the triodes
is necessary
as only one triode section is used for the voltage amplification,
while the other
triode section is used as a current source.
Roll Your Own Amp, Dude!
SE-160s are made to order, with a lead-time of 2 to 3 weeks. Mr.
Poon states
that the final sonic character of the amplifier is influenced
mainly by the owner’s
choice of tube and encourages experimentation. That way the sound
can be
tailored to the user’s personal taste (within certain limits).
Since there is only one
tube per chassis, trying a couple of different tube types ("tube
rolling") is both
affordable and fun.
The 6DJ8 tubes that came
with my review amplifiers
may not be the best
sounding choice. I tried a
few different types of tubes
in the SE-160s, including
some 7308s and 6FQ7s. I
will caution those of you
who prefer the 6FQ7/6CG7
tubes that these are taller that the 6DJ8 genre and the glass
tips on some will not
allow the amp’s top covers to be reinstalled. Those who prefer
the taller tubes
could always have the covers drilled to allow the tip of the
tube to protrude. At
any rate, I got extremely gratifying results using the shorter
tube types, so this is
not a valid cause for concern. I left the covers off when making
quick tube
comparisons to save time between listening samples. Taking the
additional time
to unscrew and then refasten the covers (16 screws in all) would
have wreaked
havoc with my short-term memory. The safety conscious can get
away with
merely laying the covers back atop the amps and putting a couple
of screws in
each cover.
Toward the end of my review process, Mr. Poon sent me a pair of
Siemens
ECC88 premium quality gold-pin tubes to try and I must admit
that they
changed my impression of the amp’s performance potential for
the better. I had
thought that the Amperex 7308s and the General Electric 6FQ7s
that I used
were in very good condition and sounded fine, yet the Siemens
ECC88s
achieved a level of focus and high frequency extension that I
did not hear
through these other tubes. I also tried the Russian Sovtek 6N1P
tubes, and
though they were possibly not quite as detailed as the E88CC
tubes, they
achieved an ideal tonal balance in my system and sounded more
at ease. The
E88CCs tended to be a little harder sounding on dynamic peaks,
and their
timbre was slightly skewed.
Of all the tubes I tried, the 6N1Ps were my favorites, followed
by the 7308s
and the E88CCs. My preference is for musicality over detail and
the 6N1Ps
offered the better blend of both attributes. Although the E88CCs
had more
detail and ultimate frequency extension than the 7308s that I
had on hand, I
preferred the more musical and natural tonal balance of the 7308s
(which grates
less on the ears over time).
The Sound: Welcome to the Grand Illusion
I first installed the Monarchy SE-160s in my alternative reference
system using
Magnepan MG 1.4 speakers (with custom outboard Walsh-type tweeters)
and
a Sonogy Black Knight high-power solid-state amplifier. My preamp
was a
B&K Pro 10, and my source was an older JVC direct-drive turntable,
with a
Grace uni-pivot arm and a vintage Micro Acoustics 3002 moving-magnet
cartridge. I did this for two reasons: first, to gauge the full-range
sound of the
amp, and second, to hear the amp with different speakers before
inserting it into
my primary reference system to power the electrostatic panels
of the
InnerSound Eros hybrid speakers.
My initial impressions were quite favorable. Compared to the presentation
of
the Sonogy Black Knight, the SE-160s appeared to have slightly
more
lower-treble emphasis, but slightly less extension into the uppermost
high
frequencies. If anything, the midrange was a bit smoother and
the bass was
quite punchy and full-bodied – not very different from the Black
Knight’s bass
performance, which is an area where the Sonogy amp excels.
Through the Maggie 1.4s, I had the impression that the SE-160s
were a bit
smoother and sweeter sounding in the midrange to upper midrange
area. This
worked very well on vocal works, brass, piano, and other midrange-rife
recordings.
The bass performance suited me (and the Maggies) just fine. It
was agile,
rhythmic and weighty; not Krell, vise-grip tight, but certainly
convincing in the
context of how real low-frequency instruments actually sound.
Speakers that
are slightly lean in the mid-bass area would welcome the SE-160s’
robust and
punchy persona.
Because of the slight highlighting I observed in the lower treble,
I was
concerned about whether or not this might become problematic
when the amps
were used to power the very extended and revealing electrostatic
panels of my
InnerSound Eros speakers. So it was with some hesitation that
I transplanted
the Monarchy amps into my reference system, usurping the critically
acclaimed
InnerSound ESL amp that I knew and loved. As it turned out, my
fears were
not justified. Upon running through various tracks on different
CDs and LPs, it
became apparent that the high-frequency character of the SE-160s
was more
synergistic with the Eros electrostats than I had assumed.
Although with some tubes the SE-160’s recreation of air and uppermost
treble
seemed very slightly truncated, when I swapped the Siemens ECC88s
for the
Amperex 7308s (and later with the Sovteks), the highest audible
frequencies
were suddenly apparent to the same approximate degree as with
the ESL amp.
Additionally, the broadband focus seemed to improve and the width
of the
soundstage appeared to widen. However, along with these improvements
came
a slight hardness, which was noticeable only in contrast to the
amp’s
presentation with the 7308s.
Getting back to that lower treble region, through the Eros, on
Gershwin’s An
American in Paris from the CD Dayful of Song (Delos DE3216) it
served the
triangle well. Chiming in from stage left, the initial strikes
and the trailing
overtones were rendered in just the right proportion and sounded
utterly natural.
"Absolutely authentic," read my listening notes. Next, on the
remastered version
of Led Zeppelin II (Atlantic 82633-2), the brush on the snare
on the song
"Moby Dick" sounded extremely convincing. Other recordings left
me with the
impression that there was a slight lower-treble aggressiveness,
but since it was
more noticeable with my digital gear than it was with my analogue
turntable
system, I thought it could have been an artifact of the digital
recording process.
At about that time, I was hearing good things about a modification
for my
Perpetual Technologies P-3A DAC, offered by ModWright LLC. To
make a
long story short, I had the modification done and I’m happy to
report that it did
indeed improve the treble presentation to the point where I could
no longer
point a critical finger. At that juncture, with the Monarchy
amps, the sound of
my digital gear (the complete system, really) became very natural
and
analogue-like. Cymbals shimmered with plenty of natural air and
focus in a way
that was very realistic and pleasing to the senses. And the upper
harmonics of
acoustic guitar seemed right and raised goose bumps with certain
recordings.
I thought the SE-160s held a slight edge over the ESL amp was
in the area of
stereo separation. Instruments seemed more distinct as they emanated
from
their respective locations within the huge multi-layered soundstage.
It appears
that you can only get that kind of separation from monoblocks,
where the two
channels are completely isolated from each other, both physically
and
electrically.
The SE-160s are very dimensional sounding amplifiers and throw
a very wide
soundstage with a good sense of depth and excellent placement
of individual
instruments and voices. Surprisingly, with both the 6N1Ps and
the ECC88
tubes, the Monarchy amps appeared to equal or perhaps exceed
the expansive
soundstage dimensions achieved by the InnerSound ESL amp. With
certain
recordings I thought the SE-160s exhibited a bit more width,
whereas the
recreation of soundstage depth varied with the individual recordings
and was a
virtual toss-up, with both contenders reproducing this aspect
equally well on
average. This is impressive considering that the ESL amp has
bested all
previous amplifiers that I’ve tried in its ability to recreate
a credible and
expansive soundstage.
Importantly, the Monarchy amps sound fast, palpable, and very
involving and
life-like when reproducing acoustic instruments. From ferocious
fortissimi on the
Grand Piano to triumphant blasts of the brass, to the agility
and sweetness of a
solo violin, the SE-160s painted a portrait of sonic splendor
with such liquidity
and finesse that on more than one occasion it raised goose bumps
and coaxed
sympathetic tears. They are that good!
"Soldier at the Brook" from Stravinsky’s L’ Histoire du Soldat
(Everest EVC
9049) is an excellent example of an emotionally involving movement.
Listening
through the SE-160s, the sprightly violin on the left and the
cello on the right
certainly sounded sweet, but there is more to it than that. One
has a clear
picture of the bow as it’s pushed and pulled across the strings,
with the short
snappy strokes of the violin contrasting nicely with the slower
and more
deliberate bowing of the cello. Here, the rosin on the bow sounds
authentic and
convincing – as opposed to the coarseness often mistaken for
fidelity – routinely
emitted by wanna-be amplifiers. (If the preceding statement seems
bold, you
have interpreted it correctly.)
Another passage that really blew me away was the finale of Rhapsody
in Blue
(Delos DE3216). Combining Litton’s passionate pounding of the
ivories with
the formidable horn section, the big bass drum, and the rest
of the orchestra,
this recording was reproduced magnificently through the Monarchy
pair. The
best part was the degree of octave-to-octave harmonic integrity
exhibited in the
reproduction of piano notes as Litton’s playing spanned the instrument’s
considerable range. I was humbled, mesmerized, and satisfied
by the scope and
plausibility that the Monarchy amps presented.
What with the dynamic and heartfelt lyrics punctuated by his poignant
acoustic
guitar, Johnny Cash’s "Down by the Train" from American Recordings
(American 9-45520-1) on vinyl raised goose bumps. The SE-160s
kept the
soul of this great artist intact. It provided a seamless transition
between the
upper and lower vocal registers, with the requisite proportion
of upper-bass
chestiness to evoke a palpable visual image of the man in black.
Truth be told,
the upper bass to lower midrange transition was more realistic
and satisfying
through the Monarchy amps than it was through my reference amplifier.
Reproduction of consonants is simply first rate, which heightened
my
comprehension of the lyrics on this and many other recordings.
Conclusion
By now it must be apparent that I am smitten by the considerable
sonic virtues
of the Monarchy Audio SE-160 amplifiers. They proved a synergistic
match in
my reference system, and I believe these amps will be happy in
most
installations, especially those that require stable, high-power
amplification. If it
were only a question of power and stability, there are surely
less expensive
amplifiers that could fill those requirements. However, for most
audiophiles,
who are rightly concerned with an amplifier’s ability to render
a convincing
facsimile of real acoustic instruments in a live venue, the choices
are few and
usually quite expensive.
Though I have used more extravagant, highly praised amplifiers
in my system,
the SE-160s paint a more convincing musical portrait those that
I’ve tried. The
fact that the audiophile can tailor the amp’s sound (by tube
swapping) to match
his taste and system characteristics is another very real benefit.
The Monarchy
SE-160 amplifiers are among a rare breed of products that can
fool the listener
into imagining he is witnessing a live musical event. I can offer
no higher praise
than that. Put them on your short list.
FJA’s Associated Equipment:
Analog Source: Michell Gyro SE II turntable;
Origin Live Rega
RB250 arm; Benz-Micro Ruby 2 cartridge
Phono Preamp: AHT/P DM Phono Stage
Digital Source: Perpetual Technologies
P-1A/P-3A combo with
ModWright LLC Signature modification
and Monolithic P3 power
supply; Parasound C/BD-2000 belt-drive
transport
Preamp: AHT tube line stage
Amplifier: InnerSound ESL amplifier
Speakers: InnerSound Eros with active
crossover/bass amp
Subwoofer: Paradigm Servo-15
Cables: Harmonic Technology silver digital
cable; Gary Markowitz’s
Remarkable Cables, and Full Spectrum
Signature interconnects;
Sonoran Desert speaker cables; AC cords:
Full Spectrum Exotic,
and Clayton Audio solid-core